Description
Interesting.
When last we were the Caretaker I had a radical shift in mood toward the game. I went from having a lovely time to hating the experience and being bitter about it in a matter of minutes. This doesn't happen often. In fact, I can recall only three other games in which this has happened - Frostpunk, IXION, and of course, Subnautica.
I gave this some thought, and I believe I have figured out the cause.
The Last Caretaker starts out with you setting your own objectives - they may be obvious, but you have the choice of what to pursue. In my case, increase my survivability by improving battery life and gathering resources, prepare the boat for departure, and then dry loot everything that isn't locked down to turn into useful materials so that I can build my own naval masterpiece while exploring waterworld. I'm going to use the phrase I so frequently come back to... player agency. My goals. My methods. My pace.
And I was thoroughly enjoying it.
Then, all of a sudden, I have to go to a specific building and do a specific thing a specific way. Agency is gone. You now have to follow One Path Only. Bait and switch. I was taken from the kind of game I enjoy into one I don't typically play. It's not that I hate story-driven games with set goals and boss battles and all those trappings. It's more that I know that's what I'm playing. It's a framing of my expectation. If I know I'm following a story, so be it. But I thought I was playing an adventure of my own making. The flipside of this is Cyberpunk 2077. I went into the game expecting to follow the story, but then discovered I had significant freedom to pursue it in my own way... my goals, my methods, my pace. The result is delight. I expected a narrow corridor and got a semi-constrained sandbox, y'know, the kind of game I love.
Subnautica was exactly the same. Imposing a specific path when I thought I had freedom.
Frostpunk and IXIOM were even worse. Giving you freedom and then screwing you over even if you did everything right. In tabletop roleplaying games this is called railroading. It is universally considered to be a bad thing.
Of course, jolly Caretaker hasn't helped itself by framing the MISSION CRITICAL device as an option. One I hadn't taken because it wasn't important to what I wanted to do. So, it forced me onto a path I wouldn't have taken, then made me unable to complete it because I lacked the mission critical piece of equipment. In design terms, that there is a faceplant.
What they should have done instead is either leave the plans as an item to be picked up, maybe label them "THESE ARE THE PLANS YOU'RE HERE FOR". Or, option two, make the scanner an item to be picked up, label it "IMPORTANT PLAN SCANNER". Don't make it a banal-sounding optional unlock. I am way more interested in refining petrol than I am in some item scanning thing. If it's not a choice, don't make it a choice, you wallys.
Anyway, I have now reframed my expectations for this experience and am ready to set sail once more with an open mind and a sense of (limited) adventure. Let's do this thing.
*****
If you'd like support the channel, join in with some multiplayer action and/or hang out with some of the friendliest people on the internet, fling less-than-a-coffee's worth of currency at one of the two destinations below and get more gubbins, including the opportunity to join members-only games and the monthly Colonel Failure "vlog", which is a vlog.
Two ways to get with the program-
Option 1 (several different tiers available): Patreon - http://patreon.com/colonelfailure
Option 2 (one size-fits all): YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/colonelfailure/join
